
Let me lay out some statistics that, considered together, seem quite improbable. First, 91 percent of college students agree that their lives are dominated by the hook-up culture. Second, the median number of hook-ups for a graduating senior is seven. That's fewer than two hook-ups a year. Only about 40 percent of those hook-ups include sexual intercourse so, technically, the typical student acquires only two new sexual partners during college.
If students agree with the rest of the panicked culture and the recent New York Times story that they are embedded in an alcohol-fuelled, porn-soaked, party scene that welcomes casual sex, how is it possible that their actual sexual activity can be described with numbers like two and seven?
This was the question that led me to rethink what was really happening on college campuses. The vast majority of published research on hook-up culture, mine included, focuses on the gender dynamics: the extent to which college women are empowered or disempowered by their experience with hook-up culture. Media coverage of the phenomenon has followed suit.
Gender, however, is not the only way to slice the data. Buried in the statistics is information about who is participating in the hook-up culture more or less actively. And, it turns out, not everyone on campus embraces the scene equally. Only 14 percent of students hook-up more than 10 times in four years and these students are more likely than others to be white, wealthy, heterosexual, able-bodied and conventionally attractive, according to quantitative studies of hook-up behaviour. Students who do not fall into these categories hook up significantly less and are more likely to disapprove of or be uninterested in the whole endeavour. To give you an idea of why, I'll briefly discuss what we know about the attitudes and behaviours of African-American versus white and working-class versus middle-class students.
African-American students are less likely to hook up than white students. Sociological studies suggest that lingering racism plays a part: Black people have been traditionally stereotyped as hypersexual (trigger warning: see the "jezebel" and "mandingo" stereotypes). So, for black men and women, embracing sexual freedom can bring individual rewards, but also risks affirming harmful beliefs about African-Americans. In response, some black people feel the need to perform a politics of respectability. In a comparison of black and white fraternities, for example, Rashawn Ray and Jason Rosow, of Indiana University, found that black men's resistance to negative racial stereotypes sometimes involved being "good" and following mainstream social norms of appearance and behaviour.
There are other, more practical reasons as well. Unpublished research led by USC graduate student Jess Butler, whose dissertation addressed hook-up culture, suggests that there may be a separate African-American hook-up scene on some colleges. However, hook-up scenes often revolve around fraternity houses and, because of historic and ongoing economic inequality, black fraternities are less likely to have houses. Meanwhile, in general, black students are more strongly in favour of gender equality and drink less alcohol than whites. Neither of these facts facilitate hook-up scripts.
Working-class students are also less likely to participate in hook-up culture. Upper-middle- and upper-class students approach college with a certain sense of entitlement. They hook up because they are fairly confident that they will spend several years working on their careers before they get married. And they feel confident that they'll graduate from college with relative ease, so they're comfortable spending a lot of time partying. Here's an example of how one class-privileged college student sees things, as reported by sociologists Laura Hamilton and Elizabeth Armstrong:
"I've always looked at college as the only time in your life when you should be a hundred percent selfish... I have the rest of my life to devote to a husband or kids or my job... but right now, it's my time."
In contrast, poor and working-class students, who are often the first ones in their families to attend college, tend to take it much more seriously and don't take for granted that they'll finish, so they party less. They also bring their values with them, so they imagine starting a family earlier. Investing in a serious boyfriend or girlfriend is more in line with these goals. As one working-class student said, in a separate study by Hamilton, about her wealthier peers:
"Some of these girls don't even go to class. It's like they just live here. They stay up until 4:00 in the morning. [I want to ask,] 'Do you guys go to class? Like what's your deal?... You're paying a lot of money for this . . . If you want to be here, then why aren't you trying harder?'"
So what we are seeing on college campuses is the same dynamic we see outside of colleges. People with privilege - based on race, class, ability, attractiveness, sexual orientation, and, yes, gender - get to set the terms for everyone else. Their ideologies dominate our discourses, their particular set of values gets to appear universal, and everyone is subject to their behavioural norms. Students feel that a hook-up culture dominates their colleges not because it is actually widely embraced, but because the people with the most power to shape campus culture like it that way.
- Author Articles
- More From This Author10 Back-to-College Skin and Hair Essentials In my last post, I highlighted some awesome tried-and-true makeup essentials for back-to-college, and this time around, I’m going to focus on must-have skin...Love a runway fashion show? You're going to have at least 10 opportunities to catch one in the next few weeks in the Metro area as the fall schedule fills with benefits and shopping events. Some will...The fashion documentary, which premiered in New York on Sept. 6, hits L.A. theaters Friday. Carine Roitfeld is a legend in the fashion business for a number of reasons: after an early modeling career she...It was the derrière that launched a thousand photos. As she gracefully carried the bride’s train up the steps of Westminster Abbey on April 29, 2011, no one could have predicted younger sister...Deconstructing Lady Gaga’s New Look: ‘Stripped Down,’ ‘Fried Egg’ It's been six months since Lady Gaga broke her hip and retreated from the public eye to convalesce in her golden wheelchair....
- Related Articles
- Related ArticlesJogging and running, whether for exercise or competition, constitute one of the most efficient ways to get in shape, trim off extra weight, and build endurance. There is no question that there are multiple...Over the last several years, more and more men have been jumping on the bandwagon when it comes to trimming the jungle below the belt. This phenomenon may have been inspired in part by the adult film industry,...Direct income businesses offer you tiny threat and huge advantages for women of all ages enthusiastic about beginning a home-centered enterprise. Regardless of whether a woman is looking to supplement her...The mobile suppliers are also just as possible to buy up OTT emails organizations if only for protecting reasons, Bernström claimed. Text messaging and VoIP functions have began consuming into...For many men – and women – depression can be severely debilitating, affecting all aspects of life. Even reproductive health can fall victim to symptoms of depression, unless the sufferer seeks help...
- Latest Articles
- Latest ArticlesThe selection of the correct grade of material as well as the right design for o-rings and gaskets is of vital importance to the sealing intergrity of the final product. Rubber sealing technology primarily...Jogging and running, whether for exercise or competition, constitute one of the most efficient ways to get in shape, trim off extra weight, and build endurance. There is no question that there are multiple...Over the last several years, more and more men have been jumping on the bandwagon when it comes to trimming the jungle below the belt. This phenomenon may have been inspired in part by the adult film industry,...Getting a better ACT Composite is such a high stakes game these days. Your test result can determine which school you get into and whether or not you get a scholarship. Each college or university...Resisting chemical attack is one of the important criteria in the design of sealing products like o-rings and sealing gaskets, and nitrile as a compound a suitable and recognised as the preferred material for...